Xi Jinping Hosts Putin: A Diplomatic Showcase Amidst Global Turmoil

Cheering children - check. Military honour guard – check. Cannon fire and marching band - check.

Vladimir Putin's welcome outside the Great Hall of the People was a near mirror image of the reception for Donald Trump last week.

Two high-stakes presidential visits, just days apart, is exactly the image Xi Jinping wants to project to the world: talking to everyone, tied to no-one.

For China, these visits are proof that because of its massive economy and newfound diplomatic clout, all roads now lead to Beijing.

The new era of world affairs is less centered around the West, says Samir Puri from Kings College London.

There is a lot of latent power that China has on the world stage; it's not necessarily using it in its most direct form to settle conflicts; instead, China's style is to try to utilize its stature in a more gradual sense.

The optics were strikingly similar - Xi confident in the spotlight as he played host. But the politics driving the two visits were very different.

Putin, who has been to China more than 20 times, appears to have a close personal relationship with Xi. However, the war in Ukraine and Western sanctions have left him leaning heavily on Beijing, which is now Russia's top trading partner and its biggest customer for oil and gas.

It has long been an unequal partnership, and this was reinforced today. Talks ended with over 20 agreements on trade and tech, but no approval yet for the stalled Russian gas pipeline that Putin has been pushing for years. A lengthy joint statement also yielded no major breakthroughs.

Both China and Russia need each other, but Russia clearly needs China more than before at the global stage, says Dr. Zheng Runyu from the Centre for Russian Studies at the East China Normal University in Shanghai.

The Chinese leader seemed to have a strong hand as he negotiated with the US president too. Stronger trade relationships with the rest of the world and China's dominance in rare earth minerals and advanced manufacturing have given him leverage. Beijing has found itself on an equal footing with Washington in the wake of Trump's unpredictability.

And in talks with both Trump and Putin, Xi faced leaders mired in costly wars that have dragged on for longer than they anticipated. For Trump, the war in the Middle East has turned into a global crisis that has plunged his approval ratings back home. For Putin, the invasion of Ukraine, now into its fifth year, has isolated Russia and taken a brutal toll even on its own people.

In both cases, it also seemed apparent that now China has the power to set the tone and the terms of how it wants to engage on the global stage.

Xi's Chinese Dream

This is a remarkable turnaround for a country that, just five years ago, appeared to be on the verge of diplomatic isolation.

Its borders were closed due to a pandemic that then-president Trump had labelled a Chinese virus. Relations with the West had deteriorated sharply amid the rise of so-called wolf warrior diplomacy, where Chinese diplomats and state media used aggressive rhetoric to quieten Western critics.

There was also growing international criticism over grave human rights abuses in Xinjiang, and Beijing's increasing control over Hong Kong, leading Western governments to impose sanctions and export controls on Chinese goods.

And yet, five years on, China has repositioned itself as an indispensable center of global diplomacy and trade.

Rather than being treated as a problem to contain, China has become a power to engage.

Beijing has moderated its diplomatic style, recognizing uncomfortable realities. Its economic slowdown means that it needs more foreign investment and trade, which require stable ties. Its excessive confrontation was also driving important trading partners in the region closer to Washington.

But the timing is also key. Ever since the US elected Donald Trump, China has repaired ties with Australia, Canada, and the UK - all key US allies. World leaders, including those from Canada, the UK, and Germany, have walked Beijing's red carpet to do deals with the world's second-largest economy.

For the last decade, Xi has promised his people he would work towards the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation, and this last week has been an incredible piece of domestic propaganda: the Chinese leader looked like the man everyone wants to meet.

But this visit also highlights the limits of China's diplomatic power.

A Diplomatic Tightrope

Xi only mentioned one war - and that was the conflict in the Middle East. He told Putin that a complete end to the war in Iran was of utmost urgency, while making no reference to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Xi and Putin both called out treacherous military strikes against other countries, the hypocritical use of negotiations as cover for preparing such strikes, the assassination of leaders of sovereign states, and the destabilization of domestic political situations in these states.

This was jarring and may have consequences beyond the Great Hall of the People. As China calls for an end to conflicts elsewhere and takes aim at US actions, its silence on Ukraine, where hundreds of thousands have died, will raise questions in Europe about how far Beijing is willing or able to act as a genuinely even-handed global player.

Beijing has tried to maintain a neutral stance in the war in Ukraine, although both the US and Europe have urged China to cut the economic lifeline it is offering Moscow. But it fears losing a key ally if Putin loses the war and is concerned about any instability in such a big neighbor.

Xi Jinping could take the easier way out and say nothing about it. Of course, tacitly this means - Russia carry on with your invasion.

With all these high-level engagements, China's authoritarian leadership, which has only grown stronger under Xi, remains controversial and mistrusted by many, showing that achieving full diplomatic legitimacy is still a complex journey for the nation.