A Utah judge on Monday ordered the release of transcripts and audio recordings from a closed-door hearing regarding whether Tyler Robinson, charged with killing Charlie Kirk, must be shackled during court proceedings. State District Judge Tony Graf required that the transcript be available on the court docket by the end of the day. Media attorneys had argued for public access to the hearing's details.
Robinson is facing aggravated murder charges for the shooting of Kirk on September 10 at Utah Valley University. Prosecutors have indicated they plan to seek the death penalty. In early October, Robinson's defense requested that he be allowed to appear in civilian clothes and without restraints, arguing this would help prevent bias among potential jurors.
Despite these requests, Judge Graf determined that Robinson could wear civilian attire but must remain restrained, citing Utah court rules requiring restraints for defendants in custody unless specified otherwise. Graf stated that the restraints are crucial for the safety of court staff and the defendant, allowing for quick security measures during proceedings.
In an effort to uphold public transparency, which Graf called foundational to the judicial system, the judge ordered limited redactions for security protocols discussed during the hearings.
Legal representatives for media outlets emphasized the need for open court proceedings to protect the integrity of the fact-finding process and maintain public confidence in judicial fairness. Graf indicated that Robinson's restraints could not be depicted in media coverage, discussing a previous incident where he halted a livestream to prevent the showcasing of the defendant's shackles.
Robinson appeared via audio link from the Utah County Jail on Monday. A preliminary hearing to present the prosecution's case against him is scheduled for the week of May 18.
