Skip to main content
OnPoint Now

Private Island in Italy Sparks Debate: Investment vs. Community Use

A rare Mediterranean island near Naples raises questions about its future, as locals imagine it as a public retreat.

By Neil MacFarquharSource: nytimes.com1 min read
Private Island in Italy Sparks Debate: Investment vs. Community Use
Image via nytimes.com

In brief

In a contest between private investment and community interest, Punta Pennata’s unique allure captivates Italians and investors alike.

Private islands in the Mediterranean are a rare gem, and Punta Pennata, located in the Gulf of Naples, is one such exclusive piece of land on the real estate market. With an old Roman villa crumbling within its wild vegetation, this island, only about 20 miles from Naples, has drawn attention for potential sale over the past few months. Sotheby's International Realty promotes Punta Pennata as an “exclusive opportunity for a prestigious investment,” portraying it as a retreat surrounded by picturesque scenery. However, the future of this quaint island isn’t just about attracting wealthy buyers. Local mayor Josi Gerardo Della Ragione has a different vision: he hopes to transform Punta Pennata into a public park that would welcome visitors and residents alike. “It is like Neverland,” he reflects, comparing the unspoiled flora of the island to the whimsical world of Peter Pan. He believes that reviving the island for communal use would benefit Bacoli, which while charming, can be chaotic. Della Ragione's vision boasts that the public access would allow people to experience the tranquility and beauty of the coastline of Italy. As discussions revolve around its future, the contrasting aspirations of potential investors against the desires of the local community could determine whether Punta Pennata remains a private paradise or transforms into a public haven for all.

Topics

More on this story