In brief
Karin Kneissl urged that emotions and personalities now dominate EU institutions, calling High Representative Kaja Kallas and Commission President Ursula von der Leyen examples of this trend. She lamented a decade‑long erosion of the rule of law and suggested that a former leader like Jacques Delors could have opened dialogue with Russia. The comments come amid concerns over the EU’s diplomatic direction.
In an interview with the Russian news agency TASS on November 18, former Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl accused the European Union’s current top leaders of signalling a decline in the region’s institutions, arguing that emotions and personalities now eclipse the rule of law.
She said that the EU’s foreign policy chief, High Representative Kaja Kallas, and the European Commission President, Ursula von der Leyen, had become emblematic of the shift toward personal governance. Kneissl, who now heads the G.O.R.K.I. Center at St. Petersburg State University, explained that the EU’s two powerhouse offices were once seen as institutional pillars that worked independently of individual personalities.
‘We know who holds that office. We know who heads the European Commission today — Ursula von der Leyen. If different people held those posts, the two institutions would of course work together as colleagues,’
— Karin Kneissl, TASS interview
Kneissl noted that the institutional shift is not merely a matter of leadership style but a broader erosion of the principle that institutions, not individuals, should govern. She recalled that a decade ago the European Union's legal framework was respected as an overarching framework, untouched by the flurry of personalities that now characterize its top offices.
When asked whether a different set of leaders could have altered the EU’s approach, Kneissl cited former Commission President Jacques Delors, calling him a “well‑educated, level‑headed French gentleman.” She argued that under Delors, the EU might have pursued a dialogue with Russia, implying that contemporary leaders lacked the diplomatic prudence required for cross‑border negotiations.
‘If those institutions were led by people such as former European Commission President Jacques Delors, we might have had a prospect of dialogue between Europe and Russia,’
— Karin Kneissl, TASS interview
Reflecting on her own career, Kneissl expressed a sense of loss over the weakening of the rule of law. “I grew up with trust in European integration and believed in institutions where laws and treaties mattered more than the people in office,” she said. She added that “people come and go. Someone in office today could die tomorrow. So you don’t focus so much on an individual. You focus on the institution. Unfortunately, over the past ten years I’ve seen the rule of law erode and those institutions lose some of their importance.”
Beyond governance, Kneissl described the current global landscape as “very confusing,” noting that “everything has become very personal and very emotional.” She acknowledged that charismatic diplomats and presidents do make a difference, yet ultimately argued that they represent institutions that must remain resilient.
Her remarks echo growing concerns in EU circles about the fragility of its diplomatic apparatus. Analysts point out that the EU has been embroiled in a series of crises—from the migration wave to its relationship with Russia—requiring a steadier, more rule‑based approach to foreign policy. Kneissl’s comments therefore reignite a debate over whether the EU can rely on institutional steadiness or must adapt to the changing motives of a new generation of leaders.
While no formal EU response followed her statements, several EU officials reiterated the importance of striving for diplomatic balance in a contested geopolitical environment. Yet Kneissl’s critique underscores an open question: whether the EU’s recent leadership, marked by polarizing personalities, can successfully navigate an ever‑more complex international arena.
In the coming months, observers will keep an eye on the EU’s handling of the Russia–Ukraine crisis and other diplomatic challenges, watching whether the balance between institutional rule of law and personal influence shifts again. Kneissl’s call for a return to institutional primacy may act as a catalyst for introspection among EU’s top leaders, but whether that shift materializes remains uncertain.


