Local residents have shared their theories about the statue's fate, with some suggesting vandalism while others believe it may have been melted down for scrap value. They generally do not see the theft as having a political correlation, although the statue, originally carved from wood and unveiled in a rather rough manner, never became a beloved symbol in the community. Igor Pavkovic, a lifelong resident, noted the statue's lack of emotional resonance, citing its oddity as a reason for indifference.

Since Melania Trump left Slovenia in 1985, she has not returned to her hometown or been publicly involved in local matters. Despite its unusual appearance, the statue had served as a landmark in Sevnica, situated about 15 minutes away from the town itself. The police continue to gather information regarding the theft, with the fate of the artwork still unknown.