Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsThe Supreme Court will examine a case from Alabama regarding the standards for proving intellectual disability in death penalty cases, focusing on the case of Joseph Clifton Smith, who has multiple borderline IQ scores and has been on death row for over two decades.

Supreme Court to Reevaluate Standards for Executing Intellectually Disabled Individuals

The Supreme Court is set to hear a pivotal case that may redefine the criteria for determining if convicted murderers qualify as intellectually disabled and thus exempt from capital punishment. The case centers on Joseph Clifton Smith from Alabama, whose varying IQ scores have prompted legal scrutiny.

Source: AP1 min read

In brief

The Supreme Court will consider arguments in a critical case regarding the execution of intellectually disabled individuals, focusing on Alabama's appeal to reinstate the death penalty for Joseph Clifton Smith. Lower courts had previously determined that Smith, with multiple IQ scores ranging from 72 to 78, should be protected from execution. The decision could impact how states assess intellectual disability in capital cases, as it revisits the balance between IQ testing and holistic assessments of an individual's mental capabilities.

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court will hear arguments Wednesday in a case that could make it harder for convicted murderers to show their lives should be spared because they are intellectually disabled.

The justices are taking up an appeal from Alabama, which wants to execute Joseph Clifton Smith, a man found to be intellectually disabled and shielded from execution by lower federal courts.

The Supreme Court prohibited execution of intellectually disabled people in a landmark ruling in 2002.

Joseph Clifton Smith, 55, was convicted of murder in 1997 for beating a man to death. His case hinges on the validity of his IQ scores, which range from 72 to 78, conflicting with a commonly accepted threshold for intellectual disability.

The ruling will impact how states approach borderline cases of mental competency concerning capital punishment. A federal judge indicated in 2021 that the case was particularly close and nuanced.

Smith's lawyers argue that a comprehensive evaluation of his capabilities is necessary to determine his intellectual status, opposing Alabama's argument that his scores above 70 disqualify him from being deemed disabled.

The outcome of the Supreme Court's deliberation will set a precedent, potentially altering the legal landscape surrounding capital punishment for those with intellectual disabilities.

Topics

More on this story