Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsPresident Trump's efforts to appoint loyalists as U.S. attorneys are being contested in federal court, with judges ruling several of these appointments unlawful. New York Attorney General Letitia James is challenging the authority of John Sarcone, appointed to oversee a probe into Trump and the NRA, claiming his position is unlawful.

Legal Challenges Mount Against Trump's Federal Prosecutor Appointees

President Donald Trump faces increasing legal obstacles as federal judges rule against his appointed U.S. attorneys, including a recent challenge in New York regarding Acting U.S. Attorney John Sarcone.

Source: AP1 min read
Legal Challenges Mount Against Trump's Federal Prosecutor Appointees
Image via AP

In brief

Recent federal court rulings have declared that Trump’s appointed U.S. attorneys for several states, including New Jersey and New York, are serving unlawfully. New York Attorney General Letitia James is contesting the legitimacy of John Sarcone's role as acting U.S. attorney, arguing that his authority is invalid, which complicates ongoing investigations into Trump. As legal battles unfold, the Trump administration's unusual appointment strategies are being scrutinized continually.

ALBANY, N.Y. — President Donald Trump's attempts to install political loyalists as top federal prosecutors have encountered significant legal challenges. Federal judges recently ruled that his appointed U.S. attorneys in New Jersey, eastern Virginia, Nevada, and Los Angeles were all serving unlawfully.

On Thursday, a federal judge listened to arguments from New York Attorney General Letitia James regarding John Sarcone, who Trump appointed as the acting U.S. attorney for northern New York. James is questioning Sarcone’s authority as he oversees a Justice Department investigation into regulatory lawsuits filed against Trump and the National Rifle Association.

Arguing in court, Attorney Hailyn Chen contended that Sarcone lacked legitimate authority, making any legal actions he undertakes — including subpoenas — invalid. She further stated that Sarcone should be disqualified from the ongoing investigation.

In response, Justice Department lawyers defended Sarcone's appointment as lawful, arguing that any motion to block subpoenas should be denied. Assistant U.S. Attorney Richard Belliss characterized the disqualification of Sarcone as drastic and extreme.
Both attorneys faced extensive questioning from U.S. District Judge Lorna G. Schofield, who has not yet indicated when she will issue a ruling.

This latest courtroom battle over Sarcone is part of a broader concern about the legality of Trump's unorthodox tactics in appointing prosecutors who might not garner the necessary Senate confirmation. A federal judge in Virginia recently dismissed indictments linked to a similar case wherein the appointed interim U.S. attorney was deemed unlawfully appointed.

Sarcone’s appointment did not follow the standard route prescribed by federal law, which necessitates Senate confirmation for U.S. attorney nominations. With no nominee from Trump for the Northern District of New York, Sarcone's unusual appointment as a special attorney has drawn significant scrutiny as it seemingly circumvents established legal procedures.

Topics

More on this story