Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsMiddle East

Gaza's Renowned Scholar Issues Rare Fatwa Criticizing Hamas's October 7 Attack

Prominent Islamic authority in Gaza condemns Hamas's actions that led to devastating war with Israel, emphasizing the violation of jihad principles.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Gaza's Renowned Scholar Issues Rare Fatwa Criticizing Hamas's October 7 Attack
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

In a pivotal moment for Gaza, Professor Dr. Salman al-Dayah issues a powerful fatwa against Hamas's October 7 attack, arguing it contravenes Islamic teachings and endangers civilians, igniting a debate on the moral implications within Palestinian society.

In a significant development amid the ongoing conflict between Hamas and Israel, Professor Dr. Salman al-Dayah, one of Gaza's leading Islamic scholars, has issued a rare and substantial fatwa condemning Hamas's attack on October 7, 2023, which precipitated widespread violence in the region. Dr. al-Dayah, a former dean at the Islamic University of Gaza, holds considerable influence over Gaza's predominantly Sunni Muslim population, making his legal interpretation critically important in shaping public opinion. The fatwa, a non-binding legal ruling rooted in Islamic jurisprudence, challenges Hamas's characterization of its military actions, arguing they violate essential principles associated with jihad. Within the six-page fatwa, Dr. al-Dayah states that the conditions for jihad must be carefully considered to avoid unnecessary harm to civilians. He elaborates, “If the pillars, causes, or conditions of jihad are not met, it must be avoided in order to avoid destroying people’s lives.” His assertion that the recent attack failed these criteria comes after the deaths of around 1,200 individuals in Israel and the subsequent loss of more than 43,400 lives in Gaza due to retaliatory strikes.Dr. al-Dayah teaches that a proper understanding of jihad necessitates a commitment to protecting non-combatants, and he cites Islamic scripture to affirm that the consequences of military actions must not exceed their intended objective. He insists on the duty of Muslim leaders to safeguard the well-being of those not engaged in fighting and calls for humanitarian provisions during conflict.This fatwa poses a delicate challenge for Hamas, which frequently uses Islamic justifications to rally support for its military actions. Dr. al-Dayah's opposition is particularly poignant given his role as a formidable voice of reform within a region rife with extremist ideologies, contrasting starkly with Hamas's militant foundations.Critics of Hamas may rally around Dr. al-Dayah's viewpoints, adding to the mounting discourse surrounding the ethical and legal ramifications of the organization’s aggressive tactics. Moreover, the fatwa could exacerbate existing fractures within Palestinian society regarding the broader strategy of armed resistance. Sheikh Ashraf Ahmed, a disciple of Dr. al-Dayah, remarked on his mentor's ethical obligation to comment amid turmoil, illustrating the scholar's unyielding commitment to Islamic principles, even under the threat of violence. He highlighted the fatwa as a historic judgment, reflecting both rigorous scholarship and moral conviction.As the conflict escalates and the humanitarian situation deteriorates, the implications of Dr. al-Dayah's fatwa may be far-reaching, influencing not only future discourse in Gaza but also shaping perceptions throughout the Arab world.

Topics

More on this story