Indian Pilots' Association Defends Air India Crash Crew Amid Speculation

The Indian Commercial Pilots' Association has released a statement defending the crew of Air India Flight 171 following calls for speculation around pilot error. The pilots’ union stresses the importance of refraining from unfounded accusations, notably regarding claims of possible pilot suicide, indicating that such narratives undermine the dignity of the profession. A preliminary report suggests potential issues with fuel-control switches but does not place blame on the pilots.

The Indian Commercial Pilots' Association (ICPA) is pushing back against speculation surrounding the tragic crash of Air India Flight 171, which occurred in June and resulted in the deaths of 260 individuals. The ICPA asserted that the flight crew acted in accordance with their training and responsibilities during challenging circumstances. They expressed concern over media narratives suggesting pilot suicide, labeling such claims as irresponsible and lacking verified evidence.

The preliminary investigation report, shared recently, did not assign fault to the pilots, indicating that mere seconds after take-off, both fuel-control switches of the Boeing 787 Dreamliner moved to a "cut-off" position, depriving the engines of necessary fuel. Although data shows the switches were subsequently returned to the "run" position, the aircraft tragically crashed within moments.

With a cockpit voice recording indicating confusion between the pilots about the fuel switches, aviation experts have highlighted the design of these switches, which are intentionally made to prevent accidental adjustment. The investigation did not clarify how the switches were engaged to the cut-off setting. In light of the report’s release, the ICPA emphasized how narratives speculating pilot culpability were both damaging and hurtful to families affected by the tragedy.

Furthermore, an alternative pilots’ union, the Airline Pilots' Association of India (ALPA India), has expressed worry about the investigation's methodology and the lack of transparency surrounding it. They noted that prior advisories regarding fuel control systems had not been adequately addressed by Air India before the incident, leading to questions about the safety compliance of the aircraft used.

Highlighting the importance of thorough and transparent inquiries, both pilots' unions have called for involvement in investigations to ensure fairness and clarity. Civil Aviation Minister Ram Mohan Naidu also echoed the need for caution in drawing conclusions before the final report is released, reinforcing confidence in the pilots and crew within India's aviation sector.

Air India Flight 171, en route from Ahmedabad to Gatwick, crashed shortly after takeoff, resulting in the loss of 241 lives on board, with one passenger miraculously surviving. The pilots had reportedly completed all required protocols before the flight, including health checks, aligning with the expectation of readiness for the operation.