Francisco Javier Remes Sánchez, a fishing association leader from Tamaulipas, Mexico, expressed his confusion over the executive order, which he sees as an unnecessary alteration to a name that reflects centuries of heritage. “That man talks a lot and we have no choice but to defend Mexico,” he noted, highlighting the gulf's significance as a natural and cultural asset since the 16th century. According to Sánchez, his dedication to fishing in the waters has shaped his life, and he spends roughly 2,000 hours annually on the gulf, underlining the personal connection many Mexicans have with the region.

The executive order, aimed at promoting “American greatness,” only applies within U.S. jurisdiction, stripping the Gulf of Mexico of its name in U.S. government documents and mapping systems. The Secretary of the Interior has been directed to ensure the new name is reflected across all federal references. However, international perceptions remain unchanged, with both Mexico and Cuba asserting that the body of water will still be recognized as the Gulf of Mexico worldwide.

President Claudia Sheinbaum of Mexico remarked on the topic with a chuckle, reinforcing that, for her country and the global community, it remains the Gulf of Mexico. The order has ignited conversations imbued with a mix of annoyance and amusement across both nations, summing up the sobering reality that a name, however changed at the federal level, does not erase historical and cultural ties that have long defined the identity of these waters.