Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsNagaland, India

Indigenous Reclamation Efforts: Naga Tribes Push to Retrieve Ancestral Skulls from UK Auction

In a symbolic fight against colonial legacy, Naga people aim to repatriate human remains displayed globally.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Indigenous Reclamation Efforts: Naga Tribes Push to Retrieve Ancestral Skulls from UK Auction
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

The ongoing effort, led by the Naga Forum for Reconciliation, underscores the emotional and spiritual significance of the return of ancestral remains amid a contested historical backdrop.

While European colonial administrators collected numerous artifacts and remains from India, the discovery of a 19th-century skull of a Naga tribesman being auctioned in the UK has sparked outrage within the Naga community. Ellen Konyak, a representative of the Naga Forum for Reconciliation (NFR), expressed her disbelief about the skull's auction, describing it as an instance of “continued colonial violence” and a painful revival of their historical trauma. The skull, originally from a Belgian collection, evoked strong reactions, leading to protests from Naga scholars and officials, including a strong letter from Nagaland’s chief minister to the Indian foreign ministry.The auction was halted following public outcry, yet it reignited calls for the repatriation of Naga ancestral remains currently housed in various foreign museums. Scholars suggest that while some remains may have been transferred consentingly, many were taken without permission, reflecting a colonial mindset. Alok Kumar Kanungo, a Naga culture scholar, highlighted that the UK hosts around 50,000 Naga artifacts across public and private collections, with the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford holding nearly 6,550 items including 41 human remains.This incident reflects a broader trend as museums grapple with ethical concerns surrounding human remains, moving away from viewing them as tourist attractions and recognizing their cultural sensitivities. Increasingly, museums worldwide are beginning to repatriate human remains to their communities of origin.As part of an ethical review, the Pitt Rivers Museum put Naga remains into storage in 2020 and no longer displays them. However, the process of repatriation is complex, often taking years due to legal and ethical research requirements. The NFR has initiated a group dubbed Recover, Restore, and Decolonise to navigate these issues, exploring the collections' origins and possible connections to current Naga descendants. Yet, according to Konyak, the movement for repatriation is not just logistical; it holds profound cultural and spiritual significance.In their outreach, the NFR has educated villagers about their ancestors' remains in foreign lands, with many elders expressing surprise at their existence abroad. This lack of awareness has made some speculate that the remains' foreign presence might disturb ancestral spirits. The colonial history has left scars within the Naga civilization, making the return of their ancestors’ remains vital to reclaiming history and establishing agency over their legacy.As Konyak reflects upon finding out that one of the listed human remains belonged to her village, she emphasizes the need for repatriation as a gesture of respect for their ancestors. “We want them back as a mark of respect to our elders,” she states, capturing the emotional weight that accompanies these calls for a return to their rightful place in Naga society.

Topics

More on this story