Judge Nathan Erasmus delivered the sentences amid emotional scenes in a Saldanha community center filled with residents. He declared that Smith and her accomplices, Jacquen Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn, would face life imprisonment on trafficking charges and additional years for kidnapping. The public erupted in applause as the verdict was announced, reflecting both relief and outrage in the community. In the aftermath of the ruling, local police vowed to continue searching for the missing child, while family members expressed their own grief and frustration over the loss.

During the trial, testimony revealed troubling insights into Smith's motives, including allegations of having sold her daughter to a traditional healer. A state witness painted a disturbing picture of Smith’s actions, and critical statements from friends and community members added to the case against her. In a heartrending appeal, Joshlin's grandmother pleaded for information on her granddaughter's whereabouts, emphasizing that no sentence could heal their family’s pain, while denouncing Smith's actions as reprehensible.

The investigation continues, as community leaders and officials reaffirm their commitment to ensuring justice for Joshlin and her family in light of this deeply troubling case.

In a society grappling with the trauma of child trafficking, the case serves as a chilling reminder of the pressing need for compassionate policies and protective measures for vulnerable children.