Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
CrimeThunder Bay, Ontario, Canada

Unmasking an Art Fraud: The Thunder Bay Deception

A deep dive into the remarkable case of art forgery that exploited the legacy of Indigenous artist Norval Morrisseau.

By Norimitsu Onishi and Brett GundlockSource: nytimes.com1 min read
Unmasking an Art Fraud: The Thunder Bay Deception
Image via nytimes.com

In brief

This article investigates the shocking art fraud rings operating in Thunder Bay, Canada, which sold thousands of forged paintings attributed to renowned Indigenous artist Norval Morrisseau, resulting in significant legal repercussions for the culprits.

In the heart of Thunder Bay, Ontario, two decades of deception surrounding the prominent Indigenous artist Norval Morrisseau culminated in a staggering art fraud case that rocked the Canadian art world. Local artist Tim Tait made a startling discovery when he tried to sell one of his own paintings to a law firm in the city. To his disbelief, he found that his work bore a different name – the signature of Morrisseau, who is often considered the "Picasso of the North."Faced with the magnitude of the forgery, Tait initially sought help from law enforcement, only to be met with skepticism and ridicule. “I was laughed at on the phone,” he recalled. Despite the dismissed claims, Tait vowed to bring these fraudsters to light, saying cryptically, “When it comes out, I’ll be singing like a bird.”Fast forward to the present, and it appears that Tait's instincts were accurate. Over the years, two criminal rings in Thunder Bay managed to produce and sell thousands of fake Morrisseau paintings. These fraudulent pieces not only bypassed the scrutiny of art galleries across Canada but found their way into the collections of unsuspecting buyers, from schoolteachers to affluent rock stars.The forgeries, often cleverly rebranded works from Tait and other Indigenous artists, netted millions in sales. As the absurdity of this deception unraveled, it revealed that Thunder Bay, often characterized by its isolation and recent surges in crime, has become the unlikely epicenter of one of the largest art frauds in Canadian history.In the past year, the masterminds behind the art fraud rings have faced justice, pleading guilty to multiple counts of conspiracy and fraud. This case serves as a grim reminder of the vulnerability of the art market and underscores the need for vigilance and integrity in the world of art authentication.

Topics

More on this story