Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsDemocratic lawmakers are challenging the legality of a U.S. Border Patrol program that uses license plate readers to monitor drivers, raising concerns about privacy violations and potential breaches of the Fourth Amendment.

Democratic Lawmakers Challenge Legality of Border Patrol's Predictive Surveillance Program

Democratic lawmakers are raising constitutional concerns over the U.S. Border Patrol's license plate reader program, which utilizes predictive intelligence to track millions of American drivers.

Source: AP1 min read
Democratic Lawmakers Challenge Legality of Border Patrol's Predictive Surveillance Program
Image via AP

In brief

A number of Democratic legislators, including Sen. Ed Markey and Rep. Dan Goldman, are questioning the legality and potential constitutional violations of the U.S. Border Patrol's license plate reader program, which targets vehicles based on suspicious patterns. This program, which was found to involve extensive surveillance practices akin to authoritarian regimes, has been criticized for undermining civil liberties and privacy rights amidst inadequate transparency and accountability.

WASHINGTON (AP) — A number of Democratic lawmakers are questioning the legality of a U.S. Border Patrol predictive intelligence program that singles out and detains drivers for suspicious travel inside the country.

Sen. Ed Markey of Massachusetts sent a letter Monday to Border Patrol’s parent agency calling the license plate reader program an invasive surveillance network that poses a serious threat to individuals’ privacy and civil liberties and raised the possibility that the program may run afoul of the U.S. Constitution.

“Such pervasive surveillance — similar to surveillance conducted by authoritarian regimes — not only chills lawful expression and assembly but also raises serious constitutional concerns. Without transparency, accountability, and clear limitations, these practices erode fundamental individual rights and set a dangerous precedent for unchecked government power,” Markey wrote, demanding details about the plate readers and their use.

An investigation by the Associated Press revealed that the U.S. Border Patrol is monitoring millions of American drivers nationwide to identify and detain individuals whose travel patterns it deems suspicious. The program has been criticized for using hidden surveillance methods, leading to constitutional concerns among lawmakers.

Courts traditionally uphold the use of license plate readers on public roads; however, they have also reinforced restrictions on warrantless access to sensitive tracking data, raising questions about the constitutionality of the program under the Fourth Amendment.

CBP officials did not immediately comment but previously stated their use of license plate readers adheres to strict policy frameworks and constitutional protections. Lawmakers are demanding transparency regarding this and other surveillance practices that could threaten individual freedoms.

—-

Contact AP’s global investigative team for more information or to share tips.

Topics

More on this story