In brief
The Supreme Court of India has affirmed that homes cannot be demolished as a punitive measure against individuals accused or convicted of crimes. This landmark ruling comes amid growing concerns over the misuse of demolition by authorities, primarily in states governed by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).
The judgment, issued on Wednesday, responds to petitions challenging the demolition of properties on the basis of criminal allegations. "The executive cannot become a judge and demolish properties. The chilling sight of a bulldozer demolishing a building reminds one of lawlessness where might was right," stated the Supreme Court. The ruling establishes mandatory procedures, requiring authorities to provide a 15-day notice to homeowners, outlining the reasons for demolition. Should a homeowner fail to respond, authorities may proceed, but the entire process must be documented on film. These measures are designed to ensure accountability and protect citizens' rights amid concerns of targeted demolitions against minority groups, particularly after communal tensions.The court's emphasis on due process comes in the wake of numerous reports indicating that demolitions have disproportionately impacted Muslim communities, even as BJP officials insist their actions are rooted in law and order. The apex court condemned the trend, asserting that "such highhanded and arbitrary actions have no place in a constitutional democracy."Amnesty International India has lauded the ruling as a crucial win for human rights, labeling the practice of punitive demolitions as "bulldozer justice." The organization underscored the importance of the ruling, despite it being a late acknowledgment of the problem.The Supreme Court's ruling marks a significant stride toward curbing the use of demolition as a tool of oppression, but experts emphasize that the successful implementation of these guidelines is essential in safeguarding justice and civil rights in India.

