In brief
Despite various advocacy efforts and Supreme Court intervention, domestic workers in India continue to face widespread abuse and lack legal protections. The need for a comprehensive framework to ensure their rights remains urgent but unmet.
Domestic workers in India, often marginalized and vulnerable, endure a harsh reality of exploitation without adequate legal protection. Take, for example, Smitha (alias), a domestic worker in Delhi over the last 28 years. Her harrowing experience of public humiliation and physical abuse at the hands of an employer underscores the systemic challenges these workers face. Accused of theft by her employer, Smitha was beaten while attempting to advocate for her unpaid wages and ultimately barred from the community where she worked. Instances like hers reflect a broader trend of mistreatment among millions in the domestic workforce, which largely comprises women from lower castes and migrant backgrounds.Last month, the Indian Supreme Court renewed calls for the federal government to consider creating protective legislation for domestic workers. However, this plea is not new. Efforts to establish legal frameworks aimed at safeguarding the rights of these workers have repeatedly failed. Previous initiatives dating back to 2008 and 2016 aimed at registering domestic workers and enhancing their working conditions still await approval. A national policy proposed in 2019, designed to integrate domestic workers into existing labor laws, has yet to be executed.This lack of legal acknowledgment leaves domestic helpers reliant on the goodwill of their employers—even for basic rights such as wage payments and time off. While official statistics suggest about 4.75 million domestic workers exist in India, the International Labour Organization posits that the true number could range from 20 to 80 million, highlighting a vast, undocumented workforce. “We possess a patronizing rather than a labor-employment relationship with domestic workers,” states Professor Neetha N from the Centre for Women's Development Studies, explaining a significant barrier to necessary regulations.Domestic work remains largely informal, falling outside standard labor protections due to the classification of private homes as non-workplaces. Advocacy frameworks have been established in at least 14 Indian states to ensure minimum wage laws for domestic workers, yet awareness of these rights remains shockingly low among those affected.Further complicating the situation is India's caste system, where social hierarchies influence the roles domestic workers are willing or able to perform. Consequently, the public perception of what constitutes domestic work must be re-evaluated. “Domestic work is perceived as unskilled, but that is misleading," asserts Sonia George from the Self Employed Women's Association (Sewa). “Caring for a sick individual or preparing a meal requires significant skill and training.”Despite ratifying the international ILO Convention 189 in 2011, India has yet to fully conform to its provisions, leaving domestic workers without crucial protections. Achieving compliance is not merely a legal obligation; it is a moral stance that India must take for the betterment of its domestic workforce. Historical inaction on protective legislation is also tied to the conflict of interests of decision-makers, many of whom are employers themselves. According to Ms. George, “Real change will require a fundamental shift in our mindset,” as long-standing cultural norms must evolve for any lasting reform to occur. The plight of domestic workers remains painfully clear, demanding urgent attention and action from India's lawmakers and society at large.


