Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsRwanda, United Kingdom

Rwanda Initiates Legal Proceedings Against UK Over Cancelled Migration Deal

In a significant move, the Rwandan government has filed a case with the Permanent Court of Arbitration against the UK, claiming unpaid dues after a controversial migrant deal was scrapped.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Rwanda Initiates Legal Proceedings Against UK Over Cancelled Migration Deal
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

The Rwandan government has taken legal action against the UK, seeking payments related to a cancelled migration deal. The case was filed at the Permanent Court of Arbitration, arguing that the UK failed to fulfill its financial commitments to host asylum seekers. This comes after Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer ended the deal in 2024, which was initially intended to deter migrants crossing the English Channel. The UK government has stated it will defend its position and is not liable for further payments.

The Rwandan government has launched legal action against the UK to seek payments it claims it is owed under a scrapped migrant deal between the two countries.

Rwanda has filed a case with the Netherlands-based Permanent Court of Arbitration, arguing the UK has failed to honour commitments made in a deal to send some asylum seekers to the African nation.

Under the deal, which was signed by the previous Conservative government, the UK agreed to make payments to Rwanda to host asylum seekers and support its economy.

But after Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer axed the deal in 2024, the Home Office said £220m in scheduled future payments will not have to be paid to Rwanda.

A Home Office spokesperson said: The previous government's Rwanda policy wasted vast sums of taxpayer time and money.

We will robustly defend our position to protect British taxpayers.

The Rwandan government has not responded to the BBC's requests for comment. But the country's ministry of foreign affairs pointed us towards an article about the arbitration proceedings in the New Times, a Rwandan newspaper.

The article states that the arbitration concerns the performance of specific commitments under the treaty.

The previous Conservative government spent some £700m on the Rwanda policy, which was intended to deter migrants from crossing the English Channel in small boats.

Only four volunteers arrived in Rwanda when the deal was in force and Sir Keir said the plan was dead and buried, shortly after Labour won the 2024 general election.

The deal included a break clause, which permitted either party to terminate it with written notice.

The £700m included £290m of payments to Rwanda. Additionally, the Home Office agreed to pay £120m upon the transfer of 300 people to Rwanda.

The New Times article quotes a government adviser stating that Rwanda had engaged in diplomatic exchanges before initiating arbitration.

Michael Butera, chief technical adviser to Rwanda's minister of justice, explained that through arbitration, Rwanda seeks a legal determination of the parties' respective rights and obligations under the treaty, in accordance with international law.

The arbitration agreement requires any disputes to be referred to the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA), which is known for resolving international disputes between states.

The PCA has the authority to issue binding, final rulings on disputes that cannot be resolved by the involved countries.

Rwanda began the arbitration proceedings under the asylum partnership agreement in November, and the PCA has listed the case's status as pending.

The PCA has yet to announce a timeline for the handling of Rwanda's complaint, which can take years to resolve.

Conservative shadow home secretary Chris Philp criticized Labour's decision to cancel the Rwanda scheme, suggesting it has resulted in potential financial repercussions for British taxpayers.

Philp asserted, This legal action means the British taxpayer is now facing a huge bill for Labour's weakness and incompetence, emphasizing that Labour failed to follow through on a significant policy.

The UK government is exploring options to reclaim funds post-scrapping of the scheme, but Rwanda has stated it is under no obligation to refund any money.

Topics

More on this story