Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
PoliticsZimbabwe

Zimbabwean Family Blames Anglican Church for Brother's Tragic Death

A sister's voice decries the Anglican Church's failure to protect children from the abuses of John Smyth, highlighting the painful consequences of negligence.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Zimbabwean Family Blames Anglican Church for Brother's Tragic Death
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

The family of a 16-year-old boy who drowned at a Christian camp in Zimbabwe is holding the Church of England accountable, reflecting on the enduring trauma stemming from the past abuses of John Smyth.

In a shocking revelation, Edith Nyachuru has placed the blame for her brother Guide's death firmly on the Church of England, expressing her belief that had they acted on past reports of abuse committed by John Smyth, her brother might still be alive. The death of Guide, who drowned under suspicious circumstances shortly after arriving at a camp run by Smyth in 1992, has raised serious questions about the church’s complicity in allowing a known abuser to operate unchecked in Zimbabwe.Edith Nyachuru emotionally recounted how her brother, a promising 16-year-old student ready to take on a leadership role as head boy at his school, tragically drowned while participating in a camp tradition where boys would swim naked. The family was informed of his death only hours after dropping him off, with shock deepening when they were barred from identifying his body due to his "indecent" state.Years earlier, a report had exposed Smyth’s history of horrific abuse towards boys under his care during the 1980s in the UK, including severe physical punishment and sexual misconduct. Despite being well-informed about these allegations, the Church of England allowed Smyth to establish a new life in Zimbabwe, where he was revered as a leader in the local Christian community and continued to inflict similar abuses on boys at his camps.Witness accounts indicate Smyth’s eerie obsession with nudity, as he encouraged boys to be naked during camp activities and even shared communal showers with them. This unsettling behavior prompted a thorough investigation into Smyth's actions after complaints from parents arose concerning severe beatings inflicted on their sons, leading to local lawyer David Coltart taking action against Smyth.Coltart's investigation revealed a harrowing pattern of violence and abuse, which culminated in a 21-page report sent to school leaders and religious institutions. However, efforts to hold Smyth accountable were stifled by legal maneuvering on his part, and the case against him languished.Despite a litany of evidence against Smyth, including testimonies from victims detailing the trauma they endured, the Anglican church's failure to adequately intervene or report his actions has left lasting scars within the community. Nyachuru is not alone in her anger, as many others affected by Smyth’s reign of terror are calling for accountability from church leaders.With numerous unresolved issues still lingering from Smyth’s actions, Coltart calls on the Church to reach out to victims and address the historical failures that allowed such abuse to flourish. The Nyachuru family continues to campaign for justice, advocating for an acknowledgment of negligence from church authorities and a commitment to ensure no other child suffers as Guide did.

Topics

More on this story