In brief
The sentence has provoked widespread condemnation from human rights advocates, citing concerns over freedom of expression under Indonesia's contentious Electronic Information and Transactions law.
An Indonesian TikToker, Ratu Thalisa, has been sentenced to almost three years in prison after an incident during a livestream where she spoke to a picture of Jesus on her phone, telling him to get a haircut. The transgender Muslim woman, who boasts over 442,000 followers on TikTok, was found guilty by a Medan court of violating an online hate-speech law, which critics argue is disproportionately used against marginalized communities. Her sentence of two years and ten months in jail has ignited backlash from human rights organizations, including Amnesty International, which described the ruling as a severe infringement on freedom of expression.During the livestream, Thalisa was responding to a comment that suggested she should appear more masculine. The court asserted her remarks posed a threat to "public order" and "religious harmony," leading to charges of blasphemy after several Christian groups lodged complaints against her. Human rights groups have condemned the decision, calling it a violation of free speech rights in Indonesia.Amnesty International’s Indonesian Executive Director, Usman Hamid, criticized the use of the country's Electronic Information and Transactions (EIT) law for social media comments, which he argued do not rise to the level of inciting violence or discrimination. “Ratu Thalisa’s comments should not warrant such a severe punishment,” he stated, urging authorities to overturn the ruling and amend problematic aspects of the EIT Law.The EIT law, first enacted in 2008 and revised in 2016, aimed to safeguard online rights. However, it has come under fire for being misused against individuals expressing their opinions, including several social media influencers. Between 2019 and 2024, over 560 individuals faced charges related to the EIT law, leading to substantial convictions for alleged defamation and hate speech.Thalisa's case stands out in Indonesia, which is predominantly Muslim, as it raises questions about religious freedom and minority rights. Legal analysts note that prosecutions usually focus on Muslims accused of offending Islam, making her charges particularly significant. Following the court’s decision, prosecutors sought a sentence of over four years, and Thalisa has a week to file an appeal against her conviction.



