Skip to main content
OnPoint Now
CrimeFrance

Man Faces Fine for Using Loudspeaker at French Train Station

A man, identified only as David, has been fined €200 for making a loudspeaker phone call at Nantes station in France, sparking a debate on public noise regulations.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Man Faces Fine for Using Loudspeaker at French Train Station
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

David's experience highlights the tension between personal communications and public decorum, raising questions about noise regulations in shared spaces like train stations. SNCF confirmed the fine but disputed details of the incident.

A man, known only as David, recently found himself in hot water after being slapped with a €200 fine for using a loudspeaker during a phone call at Nantes train station in France. Speaking to French broadcaster BFM TV, David recounted the incident, which took place on Sunday, when he was discussing matters with his sister. An SNCF employee, the state-owned French railway company, approached him and warned that he would face a €150 fine if he did not switch off the loudspeaker. David claims this amount increased to €200 after he failed to pay on the spot.In response to the fine, David has enlisted a lawyer to contest the penalty. SNCF, while confirming the fine to French publication La Parisien, has contested certain aspects of David's account, yet details of this dispute remain unresolved.David, reported to be 54 years old, initially thought the situation was a prank. However, after learning about the fine, he complied by hanging up. The incident has drawn attention, particularly since there is currently no overarching national law in France that specifically bans loudspeaker usage in public spaces. However, the French Transport Code has noise control regulations that prohibit behaviors that disturb the public peace in transport areas, which David’s case likely falls under.Public sentiment regarding loud phone calls in shared spaces is overwhelmingly negative. A YouGov survey conducted last year in Great Britain indicated that 86% of participants found speakerphone usage unacceptable, with an even higher percentage objecting to loud conversations in public.Internationally, responses to managing noise in public transport vary significantly. In the UK, train companies such as London North Eastern Railway have designated "quiet coaches,” while in Italy, Trenitalia offers “silent areas” in their business carriages to limit noise. Conversely, Japan has a strict cultural approach to phone etiquette on trains, discouraging any conversation whatsoever, while South Korea’s Busan Transportation Corporation encourages passengers to speak quietly.As David prepares to challenge the fine, the incident raises broader questions about noise regulation and public courtesy, reflecting a growing global discourse on the acceptable behaviors in communal environments.

Topics

More on this story