Skip to main content
OnPoint Now

Legal Enigma: Can Salman Rushdie’s Banned Novel Be Imported into India?

A Delhi Court’s recent ruling raises questions about the validity of a long-standing ban on Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses, prompting debate among legal experts.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Legal Enigma: Can Salman Rushdie’s Banned Novel Be Imported into India?
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses, banned in India since 1988, is at the center of a legal debate following a Delhi High Court suggestion that the original ban notification cannot be found. Residents challenge the ban, arguing it infringes on the right to read, while legal professionals weigh in on the implications.

In a surprising turn of events, the Delhi High Court has reignited the controversy surrounding Salman Rushdie's contentious novel, The Satanic Verses, which has been officially banned in India since 1988. The court's remarks suggested that the government's inability to locate the original notification of the ban may render it invalid, leading to legal inquiries about the possibility of importing the book into the country.The ongoing saga began when Sandipan Khan, a West Bengal resident, attempted to purchase Rushdie's book, only to discover that it was unpublished in India and prohibited from importation. Seeking clarity, Khan filed a Right to Information (RTI) request in 2017 to obtain the official notification for the ban, but he received little assistance from various government departments. After years of navigating through bureaucratic obstacles, he escalated the matter to the Delhi High Court in 2019, arguing that the ban hindered his freedom to access literature.On November 5, the court proclaimed it had no choice but to 'presume' that no valid notification prohibiting the book's import exists, making it uncertain whether the ban can be legally enforced. However, the ruling left ambiguity over whether or not the book could actually be accessed within India. Additionally, legal experts remain divided on whether the absence of the ban notification allows for the book's possible importation.Uddyam Mukherjee, Khan’s attorney, expressed frustration with the lack of clarity, emphasizing that federal departments also couldn't confirm the status of the ban. Former Supreme Court judge Madan Lokur added that while the absence of a notification could imply that no ban exists, the government could still issue a new notification to prohibit the book if it chose to do so.Contrasting viewpoints among legal professionals further complicate the discourse. Raju Ramachandran, another prominent lawyer, argued that the High Court's ruling simply indicates that Khan's petition became invalid, rather than granting him the right to import the book. Senior lawyer Sanjay Hegde pointed out that The Satanic Verses could already have been published in India, as only importation was banned, but the fear surrounding its distribution has deterred publishers from touching it.The issue has historical roots, with the book condemned as blasphemous among certain Muslim communities. The controversy escalated in 1989 when Iranian leader Ayatollah Khomeini issued a fatwa calling for Rushdie’s assassination, forcing the author into hiding for nearly a decade.Despite the book's official ban, access to its content within India remains challenging. In 2012, four Indian authors faced legal threats after reading excerpts from the novel at a literary festival, showcasing the cultural sensitivity surrounding Rushdie's work. Despite discussions about the legal environment regarding The Satanic Verses, the push for a reassessment of the ban’s validity continues, reflecting broader debates on freedom of expression and literature in India today. As Salman Rushdie, now 76, continues to navigate the complexities of his situation, questions remain about the future of his controversial work in the Indian literary landscape. He recently highlighted the absence of a formal review process for the book in India in his memoir, suggesting a need for dialogue on how literature is interpreted and censored.

Topics

More on this story