In brief
In a groundbreaking documentary, Olmert unveils a long-secret proposal for a two-state solution that may have altered the future of Israeli-Palestinian relations.
In 2008, former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert made a fervent appeal to Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas, presenting what he believed to be a historic opportunity for peace in the Middle East. The proposal hinged on a two-state solution that would allocate more than 94% of the occupied West Bank for the establishment of a Palestinian state, a concept that today seems almost unattainable. Olmert's map, which has taken on an almost legendary status, was never publicly revealed until now, during the documentary series "Israel and the Palestinians: The Road to 7th October," directed by filmmaker Norma Percy.In this documentary, Olmert discloses the map he presented to Abbas during a meeting in Jerusalem on September 16, 2008. This revealing moment marks the first time the former Prime Minister has shared his meticulously crafted vision with the media, which outlines his plan for territorial adjustments. The map included a proposed annexation of 4.9% of the West Bank by Israel, primarily encompassing significant Jewish settlement blocs, similar to earlier proposals from the late 1990s.Olmert arrived at the table with a compromise: Israel would yield an equal measure of its own land along the borders of the West Bank and Gaza Strip in exchange for this annexation. In an effort to connect the two Palestinian territories, the plan proposed infrastructure improvements, such as a tunnel or highway—drawn from dialogues held in the past.The heart of the matter, however, lay in the delicate situation surrounding Jerusalem. Olmert's proposition allowed each side to designate parts of the city as their respective capitals. Furthermore, a multi-national committee comprising Israel, Palestine, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and the US would oversee administration of the "holy basin" area, including the bustling Old City replete with its significant religious sites.The implications of Olmert's plan on existing Jewish settlements in the West Bank were significant. If enacted, the eviction of numerous communities scattered across the region would have been unavoidable, raising fears of violence akin to the trauma experienced by the Israeli right during the 2005 Gaza Strip evacuations led by former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. Given this context, the task of uprooting tens of thousands of settlers from the West Bank presented a dire political challenge.Despite the serious momentum behind Olmert's peace efforts, the meeting concluded without the anticipated handover of the map to Abbas, as he requested time to validate the proposal with his advisors. Even though Olmert appeared optimistic—indicating that they were on the brink of a monumental shift—the subsequent planned gathering of negotiation experts never took place. Abbas's chief of staff recalled a sense of humor in the car ride following their meeting, revealing that the Palestinians perceived the offer to be faltering, especially as Olmert's political career faced separation amid a corruption scandal.Following this tumultuous period, the geopolitical landscape shifted significantly when Benjamin Netanyahu of the Likud party, an outspoken opponent of Palestinian statehood, assumed leadership. The subsequent elections and Olmert's exit from the scene resulted in the fading of his plan, much to the disappointment of those who envisioned a chance for reconciliation.As Olmert reflects on his tenure and the stalling of the peace process, he still awaits a reply from Abbas, embodying a larger narrative of missed opportunities to resolve the long-standing Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The historical complexities have often led to the sentiment voiced by former Israeli diplomat Abba Eban, suggesting the Palestinians "never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity," amidst a landscape riddled with political upheaval and violence.In retrospect, the paths to peace continue to elude both parties, as illustrated by previous diplomatic efforts, most notably when a Palestinian delegate sketched a potential future on a napkin during the Taba negotiations in 2001. The recurrent theme of "what might have been" bleeds through each iteration of proposed solutions, as the region grapples with the unanswered questions of coexistence and stability.


